By Hugh & Rob
Voiceover Software – there are many different types, brands and makes of voiceover software on the market. This blog looks at the most popular voiceover software and makes recommendations as to what they’re used for, which are best, and why.
There are different types of voiceover software that you should specifically use during your studio recordings, be that at home in your home recording studio, or out and about. This blog is specific to that software – however, this blog looks at the generic types of software and tools you will need as a voice artist.
The Types of Voiceover Software
So what are these different types of voiceover software? What are they used for? Well, as an overview (specifically to Voiceover) these can be broken down into four broad groups:
- Audio Editors
- Multi-Track Recorders (DAW’s, or Digital Audio Workstations)
- Plugins
- Miscellaneous Voice Studio Software
This blog deals with the first two in turn. Plugins are a huge subject and a little off-topic for a discussion on Voiceover Artists requirements as they’re common to all recording software environments. For miscellaneous voiceover software, go and google Annotate and Voxover, two amazing bits of software that you may want to consider for your studio, but again out of the scope of this topic.
#1 – Audio Editors.
These are the lifeblood and the workhorses of most Voiceover Artists, and indeed radio producers, television editors, hobbyists and studio engineers around the world.
Audio editors do exactly what they say on the tin – they edit audio. In almost all cases they edit destructively, meaning that as you make a change to a file it is saved into the source audio file itself. This is important to note as it affects your workflow and how you should backup & manage your audio files.
Typical things you can do with an audio editor include:
- Recording audio in a single stream (mono or stereo) from selectable inputs
- Editing the audio file, for example selecting an area, moving it, deleting it, copying it and so on.
- Providing a visual representation of the audio file, areas you are working on, sometimes in decibels (volume) sometimes via spectral views (by pitch) and so on, with audio meters to show specific levels at various points.
- Creating new audio files
- Renaming audio files
- Processing the audio files, e.g., compressing, normalising, EQ, topping & tailing, adding delay, echo, reverb, effects, altering the volume, all of which can be done as a whole or on individual parts
- Reversing audio files
- Sorting out audio problems such as phasing, de-essing, removal of noise, pops and clicks, plosives
- Mastering your audio ready for broadcast & delivery to clients
- Changing sample rates, bit depth and filetypes, for example converting from wav files to mp3 files.
- Batching repetitive processing tasks to save huge amounts of time
The key elements of a good, professional audio editor are that they should allow all of their operations to a fine-point detail (i.e. to a sample level), have a great quality audio engine, excellent quality algorithms, be fully tested, be flexible and provide good & relevant visualisations, be stable (not crash, which many do), be constantly supported (and developed to move with the times) and be able to work in all relevant mediums and filetypes.
Examples of Audio Editors:
Sony SoundForge Pro
(Mac/Windows) – £299 / $249 Pro version, £50 / $60 Entry Versions
Sound Forge was the first editor I ever used. Back in the day I acquired a cracked version of Sound Forge 4.5 (which was old even then) and it was brilliant! I still have it on my current PC, even though I have legitimate copies of SF pro 11 and SF Audio Studio 8.
Fast forward to the time of writing and things have changed a lot. Sound Forge is now owned by Magix (having been owned by Sony for a long time) and is available in different flavours and for Mac and PC. On the PC it’s up to version 13, and on the Mac it’s now on version 3. The Mac version is still a bit buggy and is still not on par with the usability of its PC equivalent, but it’s catching up fast. For PC there is a Pro version, and a cut down version with reduced features and reduced price tag. The Sound Forge feature set is on one of the most complete – albeit the Mac version slightly less so. The PC version has Punch & Roll which the Mac version lacks. Even on the PC it’s a little hidden away and not the most usable P&R around, but it’s there – but only on the PC version.
Both PC and Mac retain the extremely useful Autotrim function. This is a process you can use to top and tail files – very useful if you’re producing IVR prompts or multiple sections of e-learning. Which handily leads into mentioning the Batch Processor. Mac and PC versions of Sound Forge Pro both include very simple to use and comprehensive batch processors (the cut down PC version lacks this feature). With the PC version it’s integrated into the main program, with the Mac it comes as a separate program called Convrt.
There are many audio formats available for you to save your audio in. Again the PC version has more available than the Mac, but I suspect that the extra ones you get on PC are old legacy formats that can’t read Mac metadata anyway. There’s certainly everything you need for 99.5% of your jobs on both platforms.
Had there been a Mac version of Sound Forge available when I moved my studio from PC to Mac I have no doubt that it would still be my editor of choice. It may well become it again.
Adobe Audition
(Mac/Windows) – Subscription Only (£20 / $21 pcm or £239 / $240 per year)
So what did I move to when I had to stop using Sound Forge? Adobe Audition.
Audition is as feature-rich and intuitive as Sound Forge, and the PC and Mac versions are as identical as they possibly can be.
Audition will do everything a VO needs, and more. The editing is simple, the plugins that come with it are perfectly adequate for what we need, and with every new version the list of what’s available grows. The latest version has a very useable punch and roll. It’s a long overdue addition, but it’s there now.
As it’s a part of Adobe’s Creative Suite it also integrates very well with the other programs in the suite, so if you need to do a bit of video editing you can use Audition alongside Premiere Pro to ensure the audio for your film is perfect.
What a lot of people consider a downside is that you can’t buy the program outright anymore, it’s a monthly (or annual – but it costs the same) subscription. The pricing structure for Creative cloud is fairly straight forward, if you only want one program you pay (currently) £19.97 per month, and if you want 2 or more you pay £49.94 per month. For your money you get 2 seats for the program, customer support, all the updates during your subscription period and 100GB of cloud storage, which can allow you to collaborate with other users or clients on projects or just work over several workstations yourself without having to manually transfer files between machines.
Audition has an effects rack – which is uncommon in an editor – which enables you to play & edit your audio through insert effects without writing the processes onto the waveform. This can help greatly in making sure your compression/EQ/other is absolutely right before committing the settings onto your audio (which is still a destructive process – this is an editor after all!).
And we must mention the Audition multi-track window. Unusually for an editor it does have multitrack capability. It’s not as fully spec’d as a proper DAW, and a fair portion of the editing is still destructive, but if you only occasionally need to produce multitrack audio or only need simple capability it will do you very well indeed.
Another big advantage to Audition is that there are lots of other VOs using it, so there’s plenty of help out there if you get stuck on something.
Audacity
(Windows & Mac) – Free
Audacity is widely used by voiceovers – it’s essentially an open-source audio editor that performs fairly well. For the money – i.e. none – it’s good and it records audio well, allowing a reasonable set of editing tools.
The elephant in the room with Audacity is that it does look/feel clunky – it’s designed by coders, and it really looks like it – it’s not particularly easy to use unless you’re already au-fait with the processes of audio recording and editing, and if you were, the chances are you’d be using something else already. It doesn’t have the best user interface and there are some key features missing, especially in terms of its metering in plugins like the compressor (there isn’t any). It also has a pretty major flaw in its programming that means it eats up space on your hard drive without some fairly careful management. But hey, it’s a free piece of voiceover software, and it’s an editor and a completely viable option for those on a budget. The latest versions are improving the usability of the program, it even has a native punch & roll feature now!
Audacity does also have a slightly functional multi-track editor, which will allow you to create mixes and mix in music with voice, but as with the rest of the program, it looks like it was designed at the start of the 90’s and isn’t that easy to use for beginners.
Personally I think you get what you pay for – it’s not as comprehensive as the paid models and does have bugs – these tend not to be fixed as quickly as it’s paid competitors by its very nature of being open-source. My own personal opinion is that if you’re on a limited budget either go and get Audition for the low entry price and work on a pro piece of kit, or preferably the cut-down version of SoundForge…but if you’re a beginner, just dipping your toe into the water and want to check it all out before you commit to much spending – this is a great option
Twisted Wave
(Mac Only) – $79
Twisted Wave is much like Audacity, but it’s not free. It’s an entry level program which is quite cheap, but it’s scope and range of editing capabilities reflects this. It doesn’t inherently have any true effects in there of its own – but it does run AU (Apple’s Audio Unit effects) and VST’s (Steinberg’s audio effects) which you can download to your computer and then use in the program.
The audio engine is ok, but like Audacity it’s got a very clunky user interface and in my opinion isn’t worth the money.
There are a couple of features that Twisted Wave has that many do not. The first one is a fully browser-based, online version which acts much like Google Sheets, i.e., it’s all hosted online, but for audio editing. I’d be really excited about this were Twisted Wave itself not just a little bit rubbish. If future development carries on and they sort out their effects and audio interface, this is an interesting prospect. And it also has a version you can use on a tablet or iPhone – this alone has helped it pick up fans, as it means you can edit on the road in the same way as you do in your studio (as long as you don’t mind editing on a tiny phone screen!).
Ocenaudio
(Mac, PC & Linux) Free
Ocenaudio is a relatively new kid on the block, with the first version being designed in 2009. It’s an audio editor, so lacks any multi-track capability, but it’s a simple to use editor and it’s free. Although it is an editor, and therefore edits destructively, it has a nice couple of features which allow you to semi-non-destructively record, and automatically backup a file before overwriting it with a new save. It also features a simple to use punch and roll for all you audiobook narrators. It has a fairly handy way of exporting different regions of audio to new files, so good for IVR or e-learning narrators. It can’t open video files so no use for any voice-to-picture work, but Hey! It’s free!
It has a few of its own effects and supports VST, so there’s plenty of scope for processing your files. You can also save to more file formats than you could ever remember in a pub quiz.
Generally it feels much more intuitive and user friendly than Audacity, so if you’re limited to a free piece of software I’d definitely go for this one over Audacity. I may even pick it over some of the paid ones.
Garageband & Sound Recorder
(Garageband Mac, SR Windows) – Free with the OS
Garageband and Sound Recorder are entry level recording tools. They are designed for literally everyone to use from children upwards, and as such do not have comprehensive toolsets at all. You cannot edit finely in these programs, they do not have good audio metering and do not have comprehensive tool suites. Garageband comes pre-installed on Macs, Sound Recorder doesn’t come pre-installed (at least it didn’t on my PC) but it is a free download from the Microsoft store.
In fact, Garageband is actually a very cut-down and free version of Apple’s Logic software, which…is great. But considering that Audacity exists, is free and is available on both Mac and Pc, there’s no need to use such a feature restricted piece of software. It’s not that it’s bad (it isn’t!), it’s just that it doesn’t do enough for you. For that reason, there’s just no point using this if you’re serious about home recording at all.
#2 – Multi-Track Sequencers (DAWS)
So Digital Audio Workstations, DAW’s, aka, multi-track sequencers or recording environments, are audio recording, editing and processing environments. They share many common factors with audio editors in that they also record, allow you to edit audio, create effects, but they are designed in a fundamentally different way and are useful for different jobs (as well as some which are the same).
One of the main differences is that DAW’s edit non-destructively. This means that if you make a change to the file, cut a region, edit out a clip or whatever, you need to ‘bounce’ or mixdown the complete session to a new file which can then be delivered to a client – during this process the original source files remain intact and unchanged.
The obvious benefit of this approach is that you can always go back to the original source point with a DAW if you screw something up, or if a client asks for changes – with an audio editor you need to have backed up the original source file or ‘copied to new’, otherwise you’re always stuck with the last saved version of your file.
Some (I say ‘some’ because the list of things you can do with pro DAW’s is quite phenomenal) of the things you typically can do with a DAW are:
- Record audio on one track
- Record audio on multi-tracks, infinitely up to the limits of your setup, e.g. 250 audio tracks, recorded & played back simultaneously
- Edit audio clips individually or across the entire track
- Create insert and send & return effects on individual tracks, and on individual files
- Mix vocals with music & sound effects
- Create music & sound effects with audio & midi, instrument libraries and effects plugins
- Record & playback to both audio & video
- Mix and master to all formats & types, including surround sound
- Use hugely versatile and expansive sub-routines (and plugins) that do many wonderous things, such as strip silence, bulk exports
- Manage your pools of audio files and audio data
- Drive and be driven by external hardware, such as Mackie devices, automated mixing desks with faders, midi triggers, midi keyboards etc.
The list goes on, and on. And on. And on.
Entire recording suites can be run with DAW’s and they are the heart of all professional (and most home) recording studio’s. They are hugely feature rich and they can be appropriately expensive!
Examples of Multi-Track Sequencers (DAWS):
Steinberg’s Cubase
(Mac/Windows)
Full Version – £400 / $549
Cubase Artist – £190 / $270
(Educational Versions typically 1/3 the price)
What can you say about Cubase. It’s difficult to describe in a few short paragraphs without just listing all it’s functionalities. Suffice to say…it is an…amazing…piece of audio software which has been developed for over 20 years having originated on the Atari ST many moons ago.
It does literally everything you could ever ask of it. 10 years ago, Steinberg’s software was full of bugs but since brought out by Yamaha it’s now very stable, immaculately designed and hugely powerful. They have, it seems, thought of everything.
The new versions of Cubase also have interactive online capabilities so you can collaborate with other artists around the world in real-time. It has VST Connect which effectively replaces ISDN, Source Connect and ipDTL…and builds that kind of peer-to-peer connection natively into the program. It has powerful Macros so you can write unlimited audio processing – I’ve used this myself extensively to bounce stepped sequences of audio files based on their filenames to specific file.
It’s a joy to use and looks fantastic – everything is colour coded, neatly hidden away until you need it and customisable to the nth degree with user-definable keyboard shortcuts, mackie controls and so on.
Steinberg of course conceived of and wrote the VST effects format which was then quickly copied by Pro Tools (their version being RTAS) and Apple (their version being AU), and they also designed the ASIO format. They own it, they develop it – and you can bet that their software works flawlessly with it. The practical upshot for you voiceover’s is that if you can think of a plugin, you can get it in VST format and it works seamlessly.
Cubase comes built in with huge audio libraries, extensive audio effects, excellent capabilities of things you may never have thought of, such as inbuilt auto-tune, time-stretching, comping facilities, looping facilities and a new way of mixing that separates itself from it’s competitors; the rest of the world is still fixated on replicating traditional mixing desks in software form, but Steinberg realised that the home production world no longer needs this, and have moved on to the benefit of it’s users.
In one of Steinberg’s biggest frustrations, Cubase is one of the most cracked and copied programs in the world – but they always have issues and bugs introduced by the cracks – I’d advise avoiding these myself. But it’s so user friendly, that it’s a testament to it’s developers that the world’s audio production members download the cracked versions over many other programs.
One of the things you’ll hear about Cubase from other audio users is that ‘it isn’t professional’ or ‘it’s not Pro Tools’ or that ‘It’s for kids who create music’ – I’m here to tell you that may have been true 10 years ago, but it’s not true now. Cubase is robust, professional and simply a joy to use.
In terms of support Steinberg also have their act sorted out – you ring up, you get through to a guy called Herman – he talks to you until your problem is fixed. They don’t charge you for it, or ask you to purchase a support pack. This is the way that all support should be.
For voiceover artists, you can probably get away with the Cubase Artists pack which is half the price of the full version as you may not need all the features that provides. If you want the VST Connect for peer-to-peer remove connections though you’ll need the full, pro version.
Don’t forget the educational version which is around a third the price. You’re going to have to prove it, but it’s well worth it.
Avid’s Pro Tools
(Mac/Windows)
Subscription Version – £25 / $30 pcm (or £299 / $360 per year)
Pro Tools First – free
Pro Tools is the big daddy of recording software. If there is an industry standard, it’s Pro Tools. Pro Tools is used across the audio industry from recording music to mixing films. Every studio I’ve ever freelanced in runs Pro Tools as their main – sometimes only – recording software. There’s even a version of it for mixing at live music venues.
Pro Tools is now owned by Avid, but it was originally designed and made by Digidesign, and there are still some legacy bits of kit and old setups that still bear that name. It used to be licensed by attaching an approved audio interface to your computer – most of which were made by Digidesign or M-audio – but since Avid bought it you are now able to use whatever interface you like and it’s licensed with an iLok (the latest versions can be licensed by iLok cloud, which means you don’t actually need the iLok plugged into your computer as long as you have an internet connection). It has now moved onto a subscription model pricing, like Adobe Audition, and not only do you get the latest software for your money, but you also get cloud storage and the ability to save your work as a ‘project’ (rather than a session) with which you can collaborate with other people. The subscription options are a bit more flexible than Adobe’s, so you can tailor your spend to your needs a bit more – which should work out cheaper!
Pro Tools First is a free version of Pro Tools, and is limited in its specifications. It only works in projects, of which you can only have 3 at once, and it has a cut down list of plugins. But it is very useable, and a good toe-in-the-water for those considering spending their money on the full product.
Customer support for Pro Tools has never been brilliant, but there is a lively user forum from which you can usually get the help you need, and as there are so many people using it there are YouTube tips and tricks a-plenty.
As Pro Tools was originally a Mac program it used to be fiddley getting it to function correctly on a PC, but other than a few optimisation issues I believe those problems have been ironed out and Pro Tools will run stably on both platforms.
You’d expect that software from one of the leading video/film editing companies in the world – Avid – would be second to none when it comes to video integration. It sort of is, but only if you use the right codec! Jobs like ADR, recording to picture and mixing to picture are a breeze with this suite, as long as you’re using the right format. If you’re not it gets jumpy and laggy.
But let’s be honest, is Pro Tools any good as voiceover software?
You bet your bottom dollar it is. It’s easily laid out and has one of the best audio engines in the world. Don’t underestimate that.
What it does it does brilliantly and there’s a reason why the majority of albums and productions around the world are done on Pro Tools. Watching a Pro Tools engineer makes things look easy.
It has a complete set of onboard effects and is an integrated music & SFX production system, as are most DAW’s. It’s midi capability has improved of late and there are almost as many AAX instruments out there as VST’s. It’s got all the features you’d expect from a DAW, such as strip silence, visualisations, and once you’ve got your head round why it works the way it does (which can be a little daunting to beginners, but effectively follows a recording studio routing model) it becomes quite intuitive.
Speaking of plugins, because Pro Tools was long seen as the industry standard, many top-end companies have developed high-end plugins for the program which aren’t available on other DAWs and if you’re into fully expert-level audio, this can be a big plus, although perhaps not relevant to VO’s.
In terms of ease of use, again, once you’ve got to grips with it (it’s not super-easy at first) things like the multi-tool become second nature and editing becomes simple. Pro Tools also has probably the best Grouping capabilities of any DAW on the market, which is simple, intuitive and how it should be.
(NB: One of the main reasons that people buy Pro Tools is because it’s the industry standard, i.e., meaning that if you want to open Pro Tools files you need Pro Tools. I’ve heard this a lot from VO’s who don’t want to be caught out. However, All the DAW’s featured here have OMF/AAF capability which is an import/export/exchange file format for multi-tracks which makes swapping between programs a non-issue.)
Apple Logic Pro X
(Mac Only)
Full Version – £199/$199
Take a look at the price tag and you can instantly see what’s attractive about this Mac only DAW. Although it’s touted as a music production system, it’s actually a fully-fledged DAW direct from Apple.
As a program, it’s effectively Garageband’s Daddy, or rather, Garageband is Logic’s son. It’s pretty user interface will feel quite familiar to users of Garageband, and Mac users will feel at home with it straight away. It uses the OSX Core Audio drivers so sounds great and runs audio, midi and has lots of great ease-of-use features like Take Management.
It has many different audio editing tools, including nifty speed fades, and has in-built samplers and Flex-Time which allows audio slicing based on transients. As well as all the normal effects, you get lots of instrument racks and instrument effects racks with a good non-destructive audio editor and cool auto-tune functions.
As you might expect, editing is easy in Logic and it’s longest running selling point is that it’s very stable – many people use a Mac loaded with Logic for live performances because it’s so unlikely to crash.
Logic isn’t as feature rich as Cubase nor Pro Tools by a long way, and it isn’t installed in as many pro studios, but what it does, it does very well indeed and makes mixing and mastering a breeze. Apple like to make things easy for you! It’s also much cheaper than it’s rivals, and this may have an impact on your choice.
Presonus Studio One
Mac and Windows
Free – £345 ($400)
Presonus Studio One is software that comes bundled with Presonus audio interfaces, but it’s not limited to their interfaces and you can buy the software and use it with almost any interface. There are 3 levels of the software, Studio One Prime is free, Artist is £85 and Professional is £345. As you’d expect there are differences between the versions.
Prime is a very functional multi-track recorder and does most things you’ll need as a VO. It has punch and roll, it will support video and the latest version (version 4) will convert your audio to mp3 which previous versions didn’t. The free version won’t support the use of vst plugins, but both paid versions will do. It can be a little fiddley to get set up, and it can be a little choosy over the audio interfaces it likes, but there are often workarounds to get things going.
Keyboard shortcuts are editable so you can customise your own workflow and it will enable you to do all the fine editing you need in a separate editor window.
Reaper
(Mac and Windows)
Full Version – $60
Last but not least, making huge waves in the industry is the newest kid on the block, Reaper. It’s making huge waves because it’s in constant development and it’s super-cheap for what it is but with good functionality. Let’s be frank, it’s very light in features compared to the big boys, but what’s there is very good and it’s developing at a fast pace.
This is so cheap in fact, that there is an argument that as a piece of voiceover software, and for all your DAW needs, this is the only choice as it has all the main things you really need.
Still, it’s multi-tracking at it’s heart, it’s got a good range of effects (again, missing some metering here and there) and it supports VST and AU formats so the world is your oyster with effects and processing. It supports Asio and Core Audio, and although it isn’t that easy on the eye, it comes with free Reaplugs, video support, elastic time stretching and much more.
For those on a budget, this is a serious contender.
Adobe Audition
Previously mentioned, the multitrack section of Audition is basic but functional. it’s not super-easy to use and definitely not as user friendly as the true DAW programs, but it does have the advantage that it’s all in one program with a brilliant audio editor. It also has most of the effects you’d need (plus it runs VST and AU plugins) and some basic level mixing & automation tools.
Steinberg’s Nuendo & Ableton Live/Live Lite
This is just a quick note to cover off Nuendo and Ableton Live. This article is aimed at looking at Voiceover Software and neither is really suitable for that use.
Nuendo is Steinberg’s answer to Pro Tools HD and contains all the features of Cubase – and a lot more. But it’s designed for professional post-production and is overkill for Voice Artists – Cubase will do you just fine!
Ableton comes bundled with various pieces of hardware and whereas it will record audio it’s designed to be an electronic music tool, and as such its audio editing capability is negligible.
Well, Now I’m Confused! How Do I Choose The Right Voiceover Software For Me?
Do I Need an Audio Editor, a DAW…or Both!?
This is an important question, and not a stupid question at all. Money and budget is a serious factor, but so is your workflow and productivity. It’s up to you to evaluate your budget but I can help with the workflow.
Remember the main difference between the two is that an audio editor is designed to edit audio files destructively, and a DAW/multitrack is designed to mix multiple tracks and larger productions together, non-destructively.
They have a different workflow and as a voice artist you’ll use them differently for different tasks.
As a professional voiceover artist though, you definitely do need an audio editor. If you’re a voiceover artist who only ever records vocals one at a time, or one voice at a time and then edits these audio files, you can probably just get away with only using an audio editor as opposed to having a DAW as well.
If you want to record your demo reels at home, or want to mix more than one track of audio together, you’re going to also need a DAW. Alternatively, if you record long form scripts, especially those which need mixing to individual files, such as IVR scripts, this is much easier to record, edit and split to individual files in a DAW….and then batch process in the audio editor (you may also find the fine editing easier in an editor, you may prefer to do that in your DAW). (Note that Audition is a viable option for both, but do remember that the multi-track version is limited and it doesn’t have the strip silence features common to DAW’s).
If you want to create Music, Sound Effects, record with proper foldback to your booth, record loop grouping or ADR looping, you’re almost definitely also going to want a DAW.
So Which Voiceover Software Should I Choose?
For Those Who Aren’t On a Budget:
Hugh says –
For me personally, on a Windows PC, I use Cubase and Soundforge. When I’m on Macs, I use Cubase and Audition. If I had my way (and mainly because of the crazy subscription prices) I’d have Sony bring their Mac SoundForge up to the same level as the Windows version, and then use Cubase and SoundForge.
Why Cubase over the others?
It’s simply the best of the lot, the easiest to use, the most flexible and the one that breaks most boundaries – it’s not tied to a complicated physical mixing desk model, and their support is just the best. I genuinely use all three of the big hitters for different things, and I always wish I was using Cubase.
Why Sound Forge? Firstly because it’s not a subscription model and you get to keep it forever, secondly because (at least on Windows) it’s the best in terms of functionality, and thirdly because it has Auto Trim/Crop, which for VO’s is essential.
Why Audition on a Mac? Because the Mac version of SoundForge isn’t quite there yet and is missing a scale on it’s waveform window – once that’s there, hopefully in the next version, we won’t be forced to rent our software from Adobe. Which is a shame, because it’s one of the best editors in the world.
Rob says –
I’d opt for ProTools and Audition.
Why ProTools?
Because I think it’s better than Cubase!
It does everything I need to do apart from file conversion! I don’t need to work between a DAW and an editor on audio projects as I can take a project from voicing to completion within the session – including fine editing and processing of individual files. It’s layout is clear and I find it the most intuitive and user-friendly recording software I’ve ever used.
Why Audition?
Hugh hints above that it’s very good! Notwithstanding the subscription thing which is frustrating, Audition provides a very comprehensive set of tools. The audio analysis capability is fantastic, and the effects rack helps it act more like a DAW than other editors do. It’s integration with the rest of Adobe’s Creative Suite make it the natural choice for those working across different media.
For Those On a Limited Budget:
For PC
The cut-down version of SoundForge and Reaper will give you a couple of great audio programs with most of what you need for only $150.
For Mac
Twisted Wave and Reaper. There is no cut down version of Sound Forge for Mac.
For Those On a Strict/Zero Budget:
If you’re looking for the best of the freebies I’d go for Ocenaudio as an editor and Studio One Prime for a DAW. 2 perfectly well appointed programs that will allow you to do a remarkable amount of pretty powerful audio editing.
For more information on voice acting visit our series of posts on how to become a voice actor
Howard Ellison says
What a useful list – homage to you for the hard work. But…with respect… I am amazed by your ‘faint praise’ for Twisted Wave. It is hugely popular, and in my view one of the most nimble and logical of editors. Really productive.
I’ve used TW daily as recorder/editor with my desk macs for six years now. In no way would I compare it to the fiddle-fingers Audacity nor, in terms of easy use, with the heavyweight packages such as Cubase that are overkill for mono voice. And, as you say, it takes plug ins (and will stack them). What’s not to like?
Hugh Edwards says
Hello Howard.
You’re welcome! This is a common feedback point I’ve had from this so far and my justification for it is that compared to SoundForge 2 which is only $20 more, it’s hugely inferior. Try them both side by side as I’ve done and you’ll instantly see what I mean. The main reason I wrote this article, and also the one about Voiceover Microphones is that (and this is just human nature) we all tend to be slightly proud and give advice that we currently have or use – you know how it goes – definitely use Twisted Wave and a Blue Yeti, or Audacity and Rode NT1 etc, and I wanted to do a fair comparison of them all
Although Twisted wave does work, and is cheap – side-by-side it’s not really that much better than Audacity is, which is free, and a million miles from SoundForge 2 which is in the same price bracket.
The fact that it might be hugely popular doesn’t really change the facts of the review! Yes it does what it does just fine, it’s just not worth the money IMO. 🙂
Re your reference to Cubase – as you can see that’s a different piece of software and has difference uses, hence the recommendations at the end for the different needs of VO’s, and why most only need audio editors, rather than DAWs. 🙂
Howard Ellison says
I have to agree with you Hugh, the SF2 has clever and detailed features, including the high-strength file-splitter and a straight-to-CD burn. Great value for sure. Perhaps I’m resistant to anything that tastes even slightly of Windows, having weathered a decade of day-job trauma before soft landing to Mac!
Leara says
I was trying to download Cool Edit Pro at the location you link to but Chrome is telling me it is unsafe. Have you tested this? I want to make sure I am not getting something nasty along with it. Thanks!
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Leara,
try this link: http://www.oldversion.com/windows/download/cool-edit-pro-2-0
Hugh Edwards says
(editors note: link updated and this may need to be run in compatibility mode for Windows XP SP3 – just right-click on the file and choose it from the compatibility options. In terms of licensing – look up the youtube videos on how to license it free – thank you Peter Quistguard!)
Michael MacGregor says
I followed the link for Cool Edit Pro 2 and it’s supposedly only free to try, $299 to buy yet the last update is from 2013. Does the trial not expire or are there limitations on features?
Hugh Edwards says
HI Michael – try this: http://www.oldversion.com/windows/download/cool-edit-pro-2-0
Hugh Edwards says
(editors note: link updated and this may need to be run in compatibility mode for Windows XP SP3 – just right-click on the file and choose it from the compatibility options. In terms of licensing – look up the youtube videos on how to license it free – thank you Peter Quistguard!)
Michael MacGregor says
So far I have been unable to find any link mentioned in any YouTube video that still works.
Hugh Edwards says
The program that you need is cep2reg.exe and peter quistguards license code.
Michael_MacGregor says
Getting frustrated. Can’t find a clean version of cep2reg.exe. Giving up on this.
Hugh Edwards says
Good luck! (give me a shout)
Anthony Rudd says
Excellent article, Hugh. I fully agree with the choices, especially Cubase. You could, theoretically use that to do your audio editing, too (I often do if it’s just an audition).
Hurrah!
Hugh Edwards says
Indeed. 🙂
Steven Jay Cohen says
You’re right Cubase is an amazing tool. I settled on Reaper since I have an audiobook focus and major studios, including Audible, have started migrating from ProTolls to Reaper.
And, you may want to add OcenAudio to your list of wave editors: http://www.stevenjaycohen.com/2014/05/21/ocenaudio-the-best-free-voiceover-software-youve-never-heard-of/
Free, and it runs on Mac, Windows, and Linux. It’s prettier than Audacity, and uses less memory. It’s a single track editor, but then again, for VO, that’s all we need most of the time.
Hugh Edwards says
Thanks Stephen – I’ll take a look.
Rafael says
Agree, and I must add that AUDACITY works on Linux from his beginning (Hugh must correct this point, cause it not only works in (Windows & Mac.
Moreover, FREE and GNU/GPL is not the same, so you Hugh, should emphasize this difference.
Thank you
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Rafael,
Thanks for the heads up!
Hugh.
Juliet says
Thanks so much for the generous information in this post! Very helpful!
Jason McCoy says
Excellent resource Hugh! I started with Cool Edit Pro years back and stuck with Adobe when they took over. I purchased CS6 right before they made Creative Cloud the only version available. I’m sure I’ll eventually go with CC once CS6 seems ancient.
Ray Greenley says
It’s great to have a list like this for people to reference. Thanks for putting it together!
I’d like to respectfully suggest you omitted a piece of software that definitely merits consideration: Studio One from Presonus (http://studioone.presonus.com/). It’s primarily designed for musicians, as so many recording software packages are, but it really is great for VO and Narration as well. It has some very powerful features (including a GREAT punch and roll function). It has a stripped down free version that you can use to get a feel for how it operates, and the basic paid version is very affordable ($99) and does pretty much anything you’d need for VO.
Denis Gessing says
Thanks, Mate for enough info to keep me busy for the rest of the week. However, the one piece of software I am considering , that did not make your list is the Rx5 plug in pac. Any thoughts there? Also a nit pick suggestion. The vertical link bar which appears on the left hand side of this article really made easy reading, well, not easy. Maybe run it at the bottom horizontally?
Thanks again.
Peter Dickson says
Hugh’s assessment of all these audio editors is excellent and invaluable. Notwithstanding his comments on Twisted Wave, I should point out that for quick recording and editing a single voice file, it is perfectly good, very intuitive and simple to use and is more than fit for purpose. Pro Tools, Cubase, Sound Forge and Adobe Audition are all fantastic apps but are a lot more complex. Horses for courses innit? Let us know your favourite!
Hugh Edwards says
Yes it’s true. It’s just that, if you do a side-by-side comparison of TW and SF2 (only $20 more), TW looks and feels babylike. Try it and you’ll see what I mean! 🙂
Renee Shatanoff says
Hello Hugh,
Reading through the various “pro” and “con” editing software, Cubase works great for a home studio voice over artist for the following two reasons (my reasons:-)):
“Cubase also have interactive online capabilities so you can collaborate with other artists around the world in real-time. It has VST Connect which effectively replaces ISDN, Source Connect and ipDTL…and builds that kind of peer-to-peer connection natively into the program.”
Several clients are requesting “listening in” on recording sessions so the VST Connect makes sense. I suppose one could use Skype or VOIP but since it’s built into the system, why not take advantage?
“In terms of support Steinberg also have their act sorted out – you ring up, you get through to a guy called Herman – he talks to you until your problem is fixed. They don’t charge you for it, or ask you to purchase a support pack. This is the way that all support should be.”
Oh my! A real, live, breathing, human being who stays with you until the problem is fixed???? AND his name is Herman???? What could be better than that:-))))
My understanding is I’ll need the Full Version for VST Connect. If I purchase Artist, can I upgrade to Full Version at a later time?
Thank you!
Renee
Hugh Edwards says
Yes you can upgrade and crossgrade with Steinberg’s products. 🙂
David Gavin Voice Over says
A wonderful look into everything across “the board” Hugh… thanks!
I would love to add it’s link to my resources page, with your permission of course 🙂 (http://davidgavinvoiceover.com/voiceover-resources.html)
I’m a long-time Logic Pro user myself, and you’re absolutely right… after the initial learning curve, it’s as user friendly as one could hope for!
Thanks again for taking the time to lay out this wealth of information!
Joe Wakeford says
Another few nods for Sony Sound Forge Pro from me and my colleagues!
David Gavin says
Hi Hugh,
Not quite sure if my last message made it through, but I just wanted to say thanks for all of the time and effort that must have gone into putting together this priceless overview!
With your permission I would love to add a link to this on my website’s vo resources page.
I’m a long-time Logic Pro user myself, but it was wonderful to see all of the options grouped together in such a cohesive way… thanks again!
Best,
David Gavin
Hugh Edwards says
Hi David – yes please, that would be great – please send me a link to see it! 🙂
Rickie Jones says
I had Audacity for a while and thought it was great. . .until I user Audition from Adobe. That has been by far my preferred software for voice over recording and mixing. Great post, thanks for sharing this information!
Rickie
Hugh Edwards says
You’re welcome! 🙂
Phil says
Excellent article, Hugh. Considering that many of the DAWs have editors as part of the programs, what is the advantage of also having a program dedicated to editing? Eg, I’m currently learning/using Reaper, which has an editor…do you feel it’s worth also investing in a separate editing program?
Thanks…btw, looking forward to your seminar August 8th.
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Phil.
The workflow in editors, batching and so on, plus the destructive nature of the editors by default is what makes them worth their money – trust me, it’s much easier to edit in an editor than the editors in the DAWS – they just don’t have the granularity or workflow as they aren’t designed for that…..:)
Emma says
Hi Hugh,
Great post, I just wanted to clarify something.
As a voice over artist I am setting up a home studio for the first time so that I can audition and record voice overs and send directly to the client. I’ll be starting from scratch in terms of learning how to use the software so I just wondered what your advice would be on what product to use? ( I am using a Mac) Do I need both an audio editor and DAW? I need the end product to be good enough for the client to use with out further edits etc.
Many thanks
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Emma. I’d probably go for Audition if that’s in your price range – it has the best of both worlds and you can always get Cubase or similar later on in your career. 🙂
Bill says
Nice advice.
Please edit your copy:
Its = possessive of it
It’s = contraction of it is
Don’t hate me because I know grammar.
Suzanne_Lamm says
Hello… I share the sentiments of others who state that this information is invaluable, and I thank you sincerely for it. I wonder though, if anybody has any thoughts about what is VI (visually impaired) friendly. I am currently using audition, but it is not as easy to use as my older Version, which I admit was rather old. I don’t even remember what version it is, but I know I’d still be using it if my husband had reformatted my computer. The subscription-based version is not near as easy for me to use as the other one was. Any thoughts? Thanks in advance.
Sue L
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Suzanne.
I would scour ebay and such for an older version! THen petition Adobe to sort their act out – it’s not really on for major software companies to not make their flagship products screen-reader compatible in this day and age.
Gary Miranda says
I’ve sworn by REAPER so far. For the handful of jobs I’ve done it’s been great. Very easy to create all my show reels with it.
But it’s major shortfall is using it for compression/normalisation. You can’t see how the waveform is changed, it gives you no dB scale beside the waveform to work with visually. And on top of that, it’s a bit more fiddly to do the very precise edits of single points on the waveform, for removing clicks etc.
I’m going to try SoundForge Pro in the new year. I’ve looked on the website – do you have any input on SoundForge Pro versus SoundForge Audio Studio.
It looks to be a cut down version.
At a quick glance, it looks like the Audio Studio version cuts out some features that sound useful such as noise removal, declicker and denoiser. Those features sound like godsends if they work. I’ll have to try them out first, to see if it’s a case of “they are actually useful” vs “it makes a hash of it so best to edit waveform manually.”
It also looks like, since writing this article, Sony have sold these products to Magix. Have they continued with the same quality as Sony?
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Gary. Yes they have. This is still to be seen! One can only hope. Byt as it standard, Soundforge Pro is a fab bit of kit on PC’s. The apple version isn’t quite there yet – but hopefully will be by the next iteration….
Candace says
I have a question.
My recording equipment came with SonarLE (which is a version of Cakewalk), and so far I’ve enjoyed it for simple recording and playback. But I can’t export to MP3 unless I pay $10 for an encoder. I need the MP3 capability very soon for something I’m working on, so I was thinking about just ditching SonarLE and using Adacity instead. I’ve already started your webinar on it, and plan to finish it this week. If you were in my position would you just pay the $10for the encoder or use Audacity instead?
Thanks!!!
Hugh Edwards says
I would continue to use Sonar and pay the $10. Audacity is a very poor program architecturally and has lots of bugs. The user interface is also pretty diabolical and it’s difficult to use. Sonar is a much better program on all counts.
Candace says
Thanks for the advice Hugh, I appreciate it!
Janina says
I’ve been using Audacity since I launched my v-o business. The simplicity has suited me well, but I’m also very familiar with its limitations (and bugs). Thanks for this information which helps me understand the benefits of stepping up and clearly presents some options.
It’s my understanding that the audio editor or DAWS dictates if you can do punch method vs. straight record. Is that correct? In the options you presented, which ones allow punch method? Or do I have a misunderstanding?
Thomas Fears says
Hey thanks for the reviews! I’m on ProTools 8, and am forced to upgrade to a current DAW for my VO work; hence, my consideration of all suitable VO solutions. I have become addicted to Pro-Tool’s Punch and Roll recording (including pre- and post-roll recording capture); which of your recommended suites offer this feature without workarounds, third-party plug-ins, coding gymnastics, or complexities?
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Thomas. The simplest is Cubase or Logic which does it natively and easily. 🙂 Audition also does it but it’s a teeny bit of a faff.
Reen Vogel says
Thanks for the great article! What are your thoughts on Reaper vs. Studio One, with regards to using it for long form narration like audiobooks?
Amy says
This is my question, too! I can’t decide between the two…
Peter Delloro says
I have been using Sonar for about ten years now and love it. It’s easy use for editing and has lots of useful extra’s. About five years ago I invested in iZotope RX. It is amazing. Now every bit of audio I record I do my rough edits with Sonar then finess things with iZotope. I am quite pleased with my final results.
Orendia Wassom says
There are a couple commenters asking about Studio One. I would also love to know! I’ve started using Studio One 3, but have considered learning other software to compare and find a favorite. Studio One vs. Reaper, how do they compare?
Heather says
It looks like Sound Forge for Mac has been updated this year. What do you think of it now? I’m trying to find software that will help me get rid of mouth noise (all the water in the world isn’t helping) and I can’t find out whether Sound Forge will do this easily. I understand that Audition does, and Izotope makes software specifically for repairing audio, but that’s an expensive proposition to have to buy it in addition to a separate editing program!
Joseph Valentinetti says
Sound forge is now Sound forge audio studio 12. With many features and ease of use and it’s 59.99 USD.
Dan says
I’d love to see an update to this post here in 2018. It looks like Sound Forge for Mac has undergone some big improvements including Sound Forge Pro Mac 3 which includes a number of iZotope plugins as well as other features. Curious about the current state of things.
Hugh Edwards says
Will do Dan. 🙂
Joel Haberli says
I have been using Garage Band for about 4 years and it works perfectly. I don’t know where you get the idea that you can’t finely edit with it… I have no problems(maybe I’m a better editor than you!). I use it not only for auditions but also for actual sessions and I’ve never had a client complain. Granted I just do VO’s… I don’t produce spots and maybe it comes up short in that regard. I’ve been doing VO’s for over 40 years and my experience is you don’t need a lot of bells and whistles… your client wants raw tracks(edited perhaps) that they can color on their end.
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Joel, Having edited over a million lines of dialogue, I can safely say that having fine edit tools like snap to zero, true snapping, crossfade editing and waveform drawing tools are essential to professional level editing. You cannot do any of that in Garageband – and although Garageband does have good points, it is an incredibly limited toolset, in favour of it’s big brother, Logic.
Lin Sagovsky says
Agree with Dan’s request for an update to this otherwise really helpful article. Especially in order to add your thoughts about Ocenaudio, which I’ve been specifically recommended for audiobooks because of the punch and roll feature, but not liked much so far. What’s your opinion?
Stefan Ashton Frank says
Im am a Logic pro guy since Atari 1040s (Notator)
In its present state it works seamlessly with picture and Source connect and my Macpro. With no 3rd party issues with Waves, RX, etc It’s always reliable never crashes and I have been making great music with it for 20 years too.
galebl says
You listed Studio One in your e-mail teaser for this blog, then omitted it from this review. That’s surprising since you hosted a seminar touting Studio One. I’ve been using Studio One 3 Pro for voice over recording and it works really well for me.
Dina says
Hi Hugh, This 2016 article is really helpful. You really spell out the essentials of each program. It is now 2019 and I was wondering what voice over editing software you would still chose?
Hugh Edwards says
Hi Dina – this was updated recently. 🙂
Kirk says
Hi Hugh, I’m currently using Twisted Wave and I’m wondering if you still feel it’s not that great?
I’ve really enjoyed everything on the site so far! Thank you to you and your team!! So fantastic!!
Hugh Edwards says
It’s ok at what it does but is hugely feature lacking. It can’t do much of what you want it to do. If you want to literally so a single track recording, it’s fine, after that, you’re restricted. 🙂
Peter Abraham says
Great post, Hugh! Thank you for the excellent suggestions and for providing the links for the same. Will check them out!
Shawn Brow says
All my questions answered…and MORE!
I am a novice vo, in ‘practice practice practice mode’, So I am using Twisted Wave FREE online. Simple, and straightforward to use, which is especially nice for an entry level student. Your review however, wonderfully explains the many options available for when I am eventually ready for demo reels and auditions.
Well done, and thank you Hugh!
Shawn
Shawn Brow says
PS . Is this the “full version” or the “artist version” for Cubase?
AMAZON (US)
Steinberg Cubase Pro 10 DAW (Cross-Grade Boxed)
by Steinberg
Price: $359.99
32-bit integer and 64-bit float audio support
VariAudio 3: Control every aspect of your audio
Revised Channel Strip: completely redesigned with new metering elements
MixConsole Snapshots: Immediate store and recall mixes to compare alternate mixes within a project
Audio Alignment: sync stacked vocals and other tracks in no time
Shawn
MarsLipowskiStudio says
This is a fantastic article indeed. But I have to say that one DAW has not been mentioned here and it should be.
I’m talking about CAKEWALK by Bandlab (Sonar). I’ve been using it for quite awhile now. I love it. It has been on the market for more than 15 years.
It is an absolute mega DAW. And after all those years IT HAS BECOME FREE.
https://www.bandlab.com/products/cakewalk
You can’t go wrong with it. You won’t be disappointed 👍🏻
All the best guys.
Kasper Michaels says
As a 2020 update, if you are using windows, Reaper has progressed leaps and bounds. I’m told it works great on Macs too, but I’m a PC muck at present. DAW nerds even talk of it rivaling Pro Tools, but I don’t know enough about Pro Tools myself. All I know is that Reaper is very easy to use, has a great support dept, and it updated often. Because it’s basically donation ware, you lose nothing for trying it out. I bought the software after the first month.
Neil Holmes says
Agreeing with Kasper about Cockos Reaper. Best $60 I’ve spent toward my audio career. Tons of effects and plug-ins and customization. Plus there are plenty of videos on their site and around the Internet to learn to use – though for me, it was a fairly steep learning curve.
Tim Bick says
Another advantage of Cubase is that it has a remote control app (another £16.99) called Cubase iC Pro for iPad or iPhone which means if you want you can use that from the vocal booth instead of having an expensive second monitor and keyboard set up.
Chris Kendall says
I was downloading the cool edit pro by clicking on the link given to you, but the browser is telling me that it is unsafe. What should I do?
Daniel Marion says
Hugh,
I have a Steinberg interface, and it comes with Cubase Elements. I’m tired of paying for subscriptions. Is it worth it to download and learn Cubase Elements?